OFFICIAL RESTAURANT NAME: New York Pizzeria
We specialize in baking a traditional New York style pizza.
With a thin (but not a cracker) crust a slice of our pizza is meant to be folded in half lengthwise and eaten New York style. Add our slightly sweet and spicy pizza sauce, our own special blend of top quality Mozzarella and Provolone Cheese, and your choice of fresh toppings, you have a combination that will have you falling in love with pizza all over again.
Unlike most places, we make our own dough every day, and we never skimp on the ingredients. We use only the highest quality, High Gluten Flour, which is needed to give our crust the proper cell structure as it rises before baking. A couple cups of honey are added to each batch, which gives our crust it's unique flavor. Every single morning, we hand-stir our pizza sauce. With Fresh tomatoes in our sauce, and all of our spices come from a local company, specializing in only the highest quality of ingredients. While we don't make our own cheese, we do grate and mix it fresh daily. It comes from our perfect mixture of Whole Milk Mozzarella and Provolone which has a very unique flavor to it's own. Every single pizza we sell is cooked on our old fashioned, stone deck oven. They may cost us more to run than the new conveyor ovens that so many other places are using, but we've always felt that ours just bake better pizza. Thank you for placing your order with us, we hope you enjoy our food and join our growing ranks of regular customers.
These are just a selection of our favorite specialty dishes and pizzas.
To see our full menu click here:
These are actual pictures of the food we make at New York pizzeria! You should expect something very similar when you order!
We are located in the shopping center on leetsdale and holly.
Adress: 600 South Holly St.
LOOK FOR: I <3 NY PIZZA SIGN!!
Very reasonable prices for very BIG slices of delicious pizza. Outside of New York, this is about the best NY style pizza to be had. My company's vehicle fleet is serviced by mechanics down the street from NY Pizzeria -- When we bring in pizzas from New York Pizzeria, the mechanics go nuts. Between friends, family, coworkers, and customers, I have yet to find anybody who didn't love the food from this place. A Yelp Reviewer
This has been our go-to pizza joint since we moved into the neighborhood a couple years ago. We've been really pleased with their pies in general. Tonight though, we got what is probably one of the best pies we've ever eaten. It was damn near perfect. Half meatball, half pepperoni mushroom and onion. The crust was beautiful. A perfect mix of crispy and chewy and just a hint of sweetness. The sauce was seriously OMG excellent. The toppings were all perfectly cooked. No raw veggies, No burnt onion tips. Super tasty. Just greasy enough. I almost wept. A Yelp Reviewer